NRR Project: 'Selections from George Gershwin’s Folk Opera Porgy and Bess' (1940, 1942)

 

NRR Project: “Selections from George Gershwin’s Folk Opera Porgy and Bess”

Music by George Gershwin; book, DuBose Heyward; lyricist Ira Gershwin

Performed by Todd Duncan, Anne Brown, et al; Decca Symphony Orchestra

Recorded 1940; 1942

This recording has a lengthy and convoluted evolution.

First of all, nobody really liked the original production in 1935; it didn’t last that long in its run (124 performances). Four days after it opened, George Gershwin supervised a recording of it in Manhattan; however, he booked two white singers – the great tenor Lawrence Tibbett and soprano Helen Jepson, instead of using the show’s original stars, Todd Duncan and Anne Brown! Why, Lord? The social climate must have still dictated that Caucasian singers were the only ones to properly interpret music. This kind of thinking would return in the 1950s, as record labels would take Black hits and re-record them with white groups to make them "acceptable."

A 1938 run of the show on the West Coast finally made the work popular. At that time, a few highlights from the production were put on record by Decca. Then, a 1942 Broadway revival caught fire and Decca decided to record many more passages from the show, and to release the 1940 material (featuring originals Duncan and Brown) and the cast of the subsequent recording session, using the 1942 personnel. Pieced together, it gives us 14 tracks in running order.

So it is not strictly speaking an original cast album, but it got the closest before the 1943 recording of Oklahoma!, which spawned the genre. (Oddly, Duncan sings Sportin’ Life’s “It Ain’t Necessarily So” here.)

Porgy and Bess is problematic in that it’s a show written by white people about Black life. DuBose Heyward, a white man, wrote the novel Porgy in 1925, and he worked with the Gershwins on the theatrical adaptation. The setting is “atmospheric;” the poor quarters of Catfish Row, Charlestown, South Carolina serve as a kind of sociological backdrop to the material. The dialogue is in “Black” dialect. It has been derided for simplifying Black behavior, of a kind of anthropological condescension.

Despite this, the opera works because of its intense emotional power. It’s a classic story of thwarted love, a universal experience. It contains some of the most memorable songs in the catalog: not just “Summertime” but “Bess, You Is My Woman Now,” “I Got Plenty O Nuttin,” and “It Ain’t Necessarily So” but also with the wrenching “My Man’s Gone Now,” “I Loves You Porgy” and the compelling hurricane scene.

Porgy is a disabled beggar, kind-hearted and noble. Bess is a young woman, the girl of a brute named Crown. Crown murders a man and escapes; Porgy takes Bess in. In the wings, Sportin’ Life, the local dope peddler, emerges and puts the moves on Bess himself.

Eventually, Porgy murders Crown, and is hauled away as a witness to the crime. Sportin’ Life lures Bess to go to New York. Porgy returns from jail to find Bess gone. He vows to follow her and win her back.

Simple. It’s a great story. It goes from one marvelous tune to another; it contains two of the most passionate duets in operatic literature. It makes you curse the gods that Gershwin died so young, at age 38 in 1937. What more might he have done? Ira Gershwin continued as a lyricist with other composers, but this was his crowning achievement.

The National Recording Registry Project tracks one writer’s expedition through all the recordings in the National Recording Registry in chronological order. Next time: Duke Ellington’s Blanton-Webster era recordings (1940-1942).