NRR Project: Piano Sonata No. 2
Composed by Charles Ives
Performed by John Kirkpatrick
Recorded 1945; released 1948
First, read Drew Massey’s excellent explanatory essay on this piece at the National Recording Registry.
At first listen, the music seems pure chaos. Is this even music, much less classical music?
It is the music of Charles Ives (1874-1954), an absolute original who followed no existing musical tradition when it came to composing. He heard music in cacophony and dissonance, and was not afraid of transcribing this completely new sound to paper. He confounded his contemporaries. (In fact, he was a weekend composer; he sold insurance for a living.) Not popular early in his career, he became noted in later decades, after he had ceased to compose.
Once you open yourself to his work through repeated listenings, you can find things you like. He can be unexpectedly lyrical. He has a stirring energy that overcomes your senses. He dots his work with hilarious musical quotations and paraphrases. Most importantly, he respects your intelligence and challenges you to hear what he hears. His work is, in its own way, beautiful.
The Sonata consists of four movements. The piece is popularly known as the “Concord Sonata.” Each movement represents an author or authors who typified the Transcendentalist movement in America during the mid-19th century. “Emerson,” “Hawthorne,” “The Alcotts,” and “Thoreau” follow each other. Interestingly, Ives stated that he saw the musical score s a mere suggestion, a platform for improvisation by the interpreter. There can not be said to be a “definitive” performance of it.
The piece was recorded in 1945, but released in 1948. Interestingly, it became a best-seller, and accelerated the general interest in the ‘til-then forgotten compositions of Charles Ives – symphonies, “sets,” overtures, songs, marches, choral works, solo piano studies, works for organ, and flat-out unclassifiable pieces. Ives was fearless and prolific.
The National Recording Registry Project tracks one writer’s expedition through all the recordings in the National Recording Registry in chronological order. Next time: “Move On Up a Little Higher”.






