NRR Project: “Tosca”
Composed by Giacomo Puccini
Performed by Maria Callas, Giuseppe Di Stefano, Tito
Gobbi, et al
La Scala Opera Orchestra, Victor de Sabata, conductor
Recorded 1953
1 hr., 48 min.
Wow. It’s simply the best opera recording of all time, that’s
all. (Read Paul Gruber's essay on it at the National Recording Registry here.)
Seen as the high-water mark of soprano Maria Callas’
recording career, it’s a ravishing reading of the highly emotional, intensely
melodic three-act tragic melodrama of 1900 by composer Giacomo Puccini.
The opera itself was adapted from Victorien Sardou’s 1887
play of the same name by Luigi Illica and Giuseppe Giacosa. The story is
gripping. As in most operas, the reactions are exaggerated and the plot is
complex. But Puccini keeps things at least plausible as the action snowballs.
As always, Puccini’s musical sense is profoundly catchy, so even if you have no
idea what’s going on you will still enjoy it.
Basically, it’s Rome, 1800. Napoleon has control, then he
doesn’t, then he does again. The chief of police, the evil Scarpia (baritone –
usually the bad guy), is hunting Italian freedom fighters. We find the painter
Cavaradossi (tenor – the tenor is always the good guy) working on a painting in
the church of Sant’Andrea della Valle; he is also a friend of the revolution.
He hides an escaped prisoner in a nearby chapel.
Then his jealous girlfriend, Tosca (soprano – the soprano is
always the heroine), a noted diva, enters. They have a spat; he tells her he
loves her. She leaves. Scarpia enters! Quickly, he and his minions search the church.
The prisoner has escaped again. Scarpia hates Cavaradossi, lusts for Tosca. Tosca
comes back. Scarpia manipulates her jealously, then has her followed. Then
Scarpia, as a procession sings the Te Deum in the background, he vows to
kill Cavaradossi and have Tosca. Crazy, right?
In Act II, we go to Scarpia’s apartment. He commands Tosca
to come to him. He busts Cavaradossi, has him brought in, tortures him, trying
to find the hiding place of the escaped prisoner. Cavaradossi refuses to rat
out his buddy, of course. Tosca arrives; her lover is dragged off. Scarpia
tortures him until Tosca reveals the hiding place. They drag the painter back
in; he’s overwrought because Tosca was a stool pigeon.
Cavaradossi is condemned to execution. Off they drag him
again. Scarpia now has a proposition. If Tosca will do the nasty with him, he
will set Cavaradossi free. She then sings the central aria (aka solo song) the
incredible Vissi d’arte, in which she sadly asks God why He has
abandoned her. She gives in. Scarpia orders up a mock execution for
Cavaradossi. Then, when he’s not looking, she stabs him to death. And leaves.
In the third act, we move to the execution ground high atop
the Castel Sant’Angelo. Poor old tortured Cavaradossi is told he has an hour to
live. He sings E lucevan le stelle, the other killer aria in the opera, about
how sad he is and how he wishes he could snog with Tosca again.
Tosca dashes in tells him to fake dying when they pretend to
shoot him. The two sing about how happy they will be. Soon they will snog! Oops,
execution time, Tosca hangs out for it. They shoot! Cavaradossi slumps! The bad
guys march away. Tosca runs up to the execution post. Hey – he’s actually dead.
Scarpia, that skunk! He is avenged from beyond the grave! Those were real
bullets. O life is bitter.
Bad guys reenter, tell Tosca to give up. She runs to the top
of the castle and flings herself off the top to her death. Curtain. (I have
heard of Toscas trampolining back up into view when they’ve flung themselves off
the parapet. I personally saw one crossing not so discreetly upstage right
after her supposed demise.)
Tosca is the grade-A emotional roller coaster that
makes it perfect for the intensity, the dark fatalism that seems to pervade it.
Every beat is efficiently carried by the music; there are little themes but it’s
not too bad; they are simply markers. The characters are three-dimensional.
When properly acted, this work is mesmerizing, impossible to ignore.
Here Maria Callas (1923-1977) shone. She made this a
signature piece of hers, her unique property, and you can hear it in this
recording. She is more fully developed in the art of acting than any other
opera singer before or since. She was vivid and clear, her tone impeccable . .
. and not affected by the wobble that plagues her later in her career. Her
phrasing, her precision make her a consummate performer whose work transcends
its genre.
Her Tosca is many things: imperious, mournful, shocked,
elated, and ultimately murderous. In killing she is protecting Cavaradossi, and
the revolution, and her autonomy. Her fate is tragic, but in Callas she is
fiercely alive.
She is ably supported by the exacting conductor Victor de
Sabata, whose only commercial opera recording this was. Her Cavaradossi, Giuseppe
Di Stefano, is in peak form. Tito Gobbi, her Scarpia, was masterful portrayer
of operatic villains who is always worth a listen. Backed by the prestigious La
Scala Opera Orchestra, the entire enterprise is first-rate. The recording is
excellent, unlike many memorable but grainy bootleg recordings of Callas.
As always with opera, you need to study up on it a bit. It
helps if you can get a translation in front of you. After a while, your brain
figures it out and you can follow along. If you must listen to only one opera,
listen to this recording of this one.
The National Recording
Registry Project tracks one writer’s expedition through all the recordings in
the National Recording Registry in chronological order. Next time: Songs by Tom Lehrer.