NRR Project: “Earth Angel (Will You Be Mine)”
Written by Jesse Belvin, Curtis Williams, and Gaynel
Hodge
Performed by the Penguins
Recorded 1954
2:57
It was the first “crossover” song from R & B to pop,
migrating easily from one genre to another. It was this group’s only hit.
This new kind of ensemble singing, denoted as “doo-wop”
after the kind of syllables chanted behind the lead tenor line, had as
ancestors the close-harmony jazz singing of such groups as the Ink Spots, the Mills
Brothers, the Boswell Sisters, and the Andrews Sisters. More recently, R &
B quartets such as the Orioles, the Flamingoes, and the Crows were performing
extensively, putting a soulful dimension into vocalizing.
The Penguins were Cleveland Duncan, Dexter Tisby, Curtis
Williams, and Bruce Tate – two tenors, one bass, one baritone – who met up in
high school in 1953. This blend of voices became the classic setup for performers in the doo-wop genre. It
was recorded as a demo in a garage in South Central Los Angeles. This primitive
(and inexpensive) kind of production helped the genre explode, until everyone
knew someone who sang on the streetcorner, hoping to hit the big time.
But this was early days. Everybody loved this song. It hit
Number One on the R & B charts, and Number Eight on the pop charts. A white
group, the Crew-Cuts, recorded a version for white listeners. That version hit
Number Three on the pop charts.
It spawned several lawsuits as to who really wrote the song. It is estimated to have sold 20 million copies over its
lifespan.
Read Lawrence Pitilli’s meditation on it here at the National Recording Registry!
The National Recording
Registry Project tracks one writer’s expedition through all the recordings in
the National Recording Registry in chronological order. Next time: A Festival of Lessons and Carols as Sung on
Christmas Eve in King’s College Chapel, Cambridge.